| 1 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £140,000 (2011) |
| 3, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £137,000 (2005) |
| 4, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 41 m² | £151,000 (2021) |
| 5 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £47,000 (1997) |
| 6, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 59 m² | £69,475 (2001) |
| 8, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 42 m² | £101,000 (2012) |
| 9, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 53 m² | £70,000 (2000) |
| 10, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 61 m² | £199,950 (2022) |
| 11 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £250,000 (2023) |
| 12, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 43 m² | £39,250 (1998) |
| 14 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 56 m² | £195,000 (2021) |
| 15 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 41 m² | £129,500 (2014) |
| 16 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Leasehold | 48 m² | £125,000 (2021) |
| 17, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 39 m² | £195,000 (2022) |
| 18 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 42 m² | £177,500 (2019) |
| 19, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 43 m² | £218,000 (2022) |
| 20 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 41 m² | £118,000 (2013) |
| 21, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 40 m² | £135,000 (2013) |
| 22, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £47,000 (1997) |
| 24, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £138,000 (2009) |
| 25, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 88 m² | £199,000 (2017) |
| 27 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £197,500 (2018) |
| 29 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 63 m² | £238,000 (2026) |
| 31, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 38 m² | £46,000 (1999) |
| 33 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 43 m² | £165,000 (2020) |
| 35 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 42 m² | £190,000 (2022) |
| 37, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 42 m² | £125,000 (2014) |
| 39 Pennywell Gardens, Ashley, New Milton, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £243,000 (2024) |
| 41 Pennywell Gardens, Ashley, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £245,000 (2026) |
| 43 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £87,000 (2001) |
| 45 Pennywell Gardens, Ashley, New Milton, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £133,500 (2005) |
| 47, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £195,000 (2020) |
| 49 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £255,000 (2024) |
| 51 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £210,000 (2018) |
| 53, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 52 m² | £255,000 (2024) |
| 55, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £269,000 (2022) |
| 57 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | - | 64 m² | - |
| 59 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 42 m² | £122,500 (2014) |
| 61, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 39 m² | £110,000 (2011) |
| 63 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £150,000 (2014) |
| 65, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 53 m² | £219,000 (2020) |
| 67, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £204,950 (2017) |
| 71 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £233,000 (2025) |
| 75, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 59 m² | £89,500 (2002) |
| 79, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 52 m² | £147,250 (2010) |
| 81 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £255,000 (2023) |
| 83 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £232,000 (2023) |
| 85 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | - | 51 m² | - |
| 87, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 53 m² | £210,000 (2019) |
| 89 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 52 m² | £85,000 (2001) |
| 91 Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 50 m² | £199,000 (2021) |
| 93, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 51 m² | £280,000 (2022) |
| 95, Pennywell Gardens, New Milton | Freehold | 53 m² | £242,640 (2023) |