| 1 Castle Courtyard, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 136 m² | £105,000 (2003) |
| 2 Castle Courtyard, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 79 m² | £58,125 (2003) |
| Allendale, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 137 m² | £280,000 (2014) |
| Bank Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 135 m² | £270,000 (2015) |
| Bankfoot, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 282 m² | £780,000 (2025) |
| Barn Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 160 m² | £405,000 (2024) |
| Braeside, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 81 m² | - |
| Castle House, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 235 m² | - |
| Croft Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 218 m² | - |
| Croft House, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 214 m² | - |
| Fir Bank, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 270 m² | - |
| Fir Tree Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 93 m² | £235,000 (2012) |
| Hartley Castle Barn, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 84 m² | - |
| Hartley House, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 236 m² | £515,000 (2014) |
| Hellgill Howe Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 205 m² | £475,000 (2021) |
| High Croft, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | - | 260 m² | - |
| Kirkby View, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 260 m² | £128,500 (2015) |
| Murton Holme, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 269 m² | £490,000 (2008) |
| New End, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 78 m² | £205,000 (2019) |
| Salt Pie Hall, Hartley On The C3079 From The U3431 To Slackgap Lane, Hartley, Hartley | Freehold | 165 m² | £472,500 (2020) |
| The Cottage, Hartley, Kirkby Stephen | Freehold | 108 m² | £162,500 (2009) |
| Wearcot, Hartley On The C3079 From The U3431 To Slackgap Lane, Hartley, Hartley | Freehold | 133 m² | £340,000 (2021) |