| Buds Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 97 m² | - |
| Carley Garth, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 137 m² | £375,000 (2010) |
| Croxford, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 84 m² | - |
| Dial House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 167 m² | - |
| Fairview, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 89 m² | - |
| Hillcrest, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 86 m² | £230,000 (2017) |
| Hillside, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 52 m² | £165,000 (2006) |
| Laurel Tree Barn, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 54 m² | £285,000 (2019) |
| Loaning View, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 91 m² | £260,000 (2018) |
| Middehus, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 85 m² | £187,500 (2020) |
| Neigarth, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 93 m² | £245,200 (2021) |
| Old Reading Rooms, Preston Under Scar To Redmire Road, Preston Under Scar, Preston Under Scar | Freehold | 138 m² | £170,000 (2013) |
| Penhill Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 97 m² | - |
| Preston Moor Farm, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 219 m² | - |
| Preston Springs Garth, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 132 m² | - |
| Preston Springs House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 313 m² | - |
| Primrose Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 53 m² | £225,000 (2020) |
| Rock Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 76 m² | £287,500 (2016) |
| Rock View, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 161 m² | £212,000 (2017) |
| Stonegate, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 78 m² | - |
| Sunshine Cottage, Preston Under Scar, North Yorkshire | - | 54 m² | - |
| The Cosh, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 90 m² | £300,000 (2021) |
| The White House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 139 m² | - |
