| Archway Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 115 m² | £228,500 (2013) |
| Eastend Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 81 m² | £230,000 (2024) |
| Emcot, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 136 m² | £372,000 (2020) |
| High Wood Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 74 m² | - |
| Keldholme, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn, North Yorkshire | - | 217 m² | - |
| Mallyan House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 269 m² | - |
| Manor House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 134 m² | £375,000 (2010) |
| Penhill View, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 130 m² | £304,960 (2020) |
| Preston Mill Barn, Preston Mill, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 31 m² | £475,000 (2025) |
| Prospect House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 87 m² | - |
| Rosemary Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 68 m² | £152,000 (2011) |
| Sakhir Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 91 m² | £130,000 (2002) |
| Scar House, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 157 m² | £495,000 (2007) |
| Scarthwaite, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 241 m² | £440,000 (2018) |
| Smithy Cottage, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | - | 136 m² | - |
| The Old Smithy, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 83 m² | £225,000 (2015) |
| The Orchard, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 124 m² | £97,000 (1996) |
| The Setts, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 98 m² | £250,000 (2004) |
| Underscar, Preston Under Scar, Leyburn | Freehold | 128 m² | £320,000 (2019) |
