| 1 Langton Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 117 m² | £195,000 (2012) |
| 2 Council House, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 84 m² | £180,000 (2025) |
| 5, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 99 m² | £218,000 (2017) |
| Creg Ny Ba, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 118 m² | £213,500 (2005) |
| Curly Coats, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 78 m² | - |
| Field House, Langton Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 194 m² | £300,000 (2011) |
| Green Man Cottage, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 114 m² | £230,000 (2015) |
| Laburnum Cottage, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 194 m² | £55,000 (2000) |
| Lanesend Cottage, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 59 m² | - |
| Langton House, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 292 m² | £575,000 (2019) |
| Marlborough, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 175 m² | - |
| Meadow Lands, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 80 m² | - |
| Mill Brook, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 167 m² | £480,000 (2026) |
| Mydwelin, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 181 m² | £125,000 (2014) |
| Pembury, Mill Lane, Horncastle | - | 73 m² | - |
| Stockmans Rest, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 118 m² | £238,000 (2015) |
| Terene, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 98 m² | £154,000 (2014) |
| The Beeches, Mill Lane, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 88 m² | £260,000 (2025) |
