| Apple Tree House, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 208 m² | £451,250 (2020) |
| Beechdene, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 233 m² | £189,950 (2001) |
| Brambles, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 146 m² | - |
| Chestnut House, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 257 m² | £475,000 (2019) |
| Church Corner, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 143 m² | - |
| Copperfields, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 130 m² | - |
| Criffel Cottage, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 61 m² | £220,000 (2025) |
| Elmhurst, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 92 m² | - |
| Fair View, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 73 m² | £52,500 (2000) |
| Farmlea, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 258 m² | £460,000 (2021) |
| Goes Cottage, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 135 m² | - |
| Hallgarth Farm Bungalow, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 121 m² | - |
| Hallgarth Farm, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 301 m² | - |
| Hebron, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 140 m² | £250,000 (2019) |
| Hollow Park, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 220 m² | £470,000 (2014) |
| Laburnum House, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 141 m² | £203,000 (2006) |
| Maple Lodge, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 108 m² | - |
| Old Manor House, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 195 m² | £615,000 (2023) |
| Pentlands, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 186 m² | £431,000 (2020) |
| Rose Cottage, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 34 m² | - |
| School House, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 53 m² | - |
| Thatched Cottage, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 57 m² | £225,000 (2014) |
| The Barn, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 194 m² | - |
| The Cabin, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 53 m² | £139,000 (2015) |
| The Foundry Hallgarth Farm, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 80 m² | - |
| The Old Forge, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 207 m² | £313,000 (2013) |
| The Saddlery Hallgarth Farm, Thimbleby, Horncastle | - | 108 m² | - |
| Village Farm, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 181 m² | £380,000 (2013) |
| Wayside, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 175 m² | £385,000 (2016) |
| White House Farm, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 126 m² | £325,000 (2004) |
| Willow Cottage, Thimbleby, Horncastle | Freehold | 123 m² | £395,000 (2022) |