| 1 New Ramsden Row, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 94 m² | - |
| 1 Old Mill Cottages, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 178 m² | £475,000 (2023) |
| 2 Huthwaite Bank, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 155 m² | - |
| 2 Old Mill Cottages, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 195 m² | £368,500 (2021) |
| 26 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 97 m² | - |
| 43, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 94 m² | £450,000 (2018) |
| 45 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 172 m² | £415,000 (2021) |
| 49 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 220 m² | £630,000 (2023) |
| 53 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Barnsley, Barnsley | Freehold | 152 m² | £415,000 (2025) |
| Birch Croft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 110 m² | £430,000 (2025) |
| Booth House, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 160 m² | - |
| Cherry Cote Hall, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 87 m² | £246,000 (2009) |
| Don House, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 130 m² | £750,000 (2023) |
| Fiddler Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 132 m² | £675,000 (2018) |
| Furnace Cottage, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 102 m² | £270,000 (2017) |
| Huthwaite Bank Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 183 m² | - |
| Inglenook, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £270,000 (2022) |
| Ivy Cottage, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 85 m² | - |
| Jephcote, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 197 m² | £110,000 (2001) |
| New Barn Cottage, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 165 m² | - |
| Rivelin, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 91 m² | £340,000 (2021) |
| River Dale, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 328 m² | - |
| River Mill Barn, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 134 m² | - |
| Rivermill Farm, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 166 m² | £319,950 (2006) |
| Stonecroft, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 276 m² | - |
| Stones Wood View, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 180 m² | - |
| The Old Wire Mill, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 180 m² | £600,000 (2010) |
| Tilt Mill House, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 219 m² | £210,000 (2003) |
| Tree View, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 210 m² | £500,000 (2021) |
| Vale House, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Barnsley | - | 187 m² | - |
| Wantacyu, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | Freehold | 95 m² | £310,000 (2025) |
| Waterfall Cottage, Old Mill Lane, Sheffield | Freehold | 179 m² | £550,000 (2017) |
| Woodman House, Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield | - | 287 m² | - |