| 1A, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 82 m² | - |
| 2 Church Street, Penistone, Barnsley, Barnsley | Freehold | 48 m² | £87,500 (2012) |
| 3 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 79 m² | - |
| 8, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 59 m² | £120,000 (2018) |
| 10, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 47 m² | £98,000 (2014) |
| 11, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 61 m² | £90,000 (2025) |
| 14, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 53 m² | £110,820 (2023) |
| 16 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 45 m² | £60,000 (2024) |
| 17, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 47 m² | £39,950 (2000) |
| 18 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 45 m² | £101,000 (2023) |
| 19, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 47 m² | £89,950 (2017) |
| 22 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 42 m² | £86,000 (2011) |
| 23, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 53 m² | £98,000 (2013) |
| 25, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 48 m² | £112,000 (2017) |
| 26 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 59 m² | £134,500 (2021) |
| 27 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 48 m² | £130,000 (2021) |
| 29, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 90 m² | £148,500 (2021) |
| 31, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 76 m² | £140,000 (2021) |
| 35, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 92 m² | £109,950 (2006) |
| 37, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 97 m² | £119,000 (2005) |
| 41, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 115 m² | - |
| 43 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 122 m² | £260,000 (2024) |
| 47 Church Street, Penistone, Barnsley | - | 52 m² | - |
| 53 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 57 m² | £119,950 (2007) |
| 55, Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 57 m² | £87,600 (2020) |
| 59 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 57 m² | £102,000 (2014) |
| The Flat, 1 Church Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 47 m² | - |