| 1 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 78 m² | £246,995 (2023) |
| 3 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 78 m² | £284,995 (2023) |
| 5 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Leasehold | 75 m² | £69,998 (2024) |
| 7 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | - | 75 m² | - |
| 9 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | - | 75 m² | - |
| 11 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 75 m² | £163,185 (2023) |
| 15 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 78 m² | £279,995 (2024) |
| 17 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £265,996 (2024) |
| 19 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £263,119 (2024) |
| 21 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £335,995 (2024) |
| 23 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 98 m² | £374,995 (2025) |
| 25 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £335,995 (2024) |
| 27 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 98 m² | £357,995 (2024) |
| 29 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 98 m² | £371,995 (2024) |
| 31 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 77 m² | £266,905 (2024) |
| 33 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 77 m² | £266,918 (2024) |
| 35 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £339,995 (2024) |
| 37 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £336,995 (2024) |
| 39 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 98 m² | £378,145 (2024) |
| 41 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 92 m² | £344,495 (2025) |
| 43 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 68 m² | £153,212 (2024) |
| 45 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 68 m² | £153,212 (2024) |
| 47 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 68 m² | £153,212 (2024) |
| 49 Thurlstone Moor Avenue, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 92 m² | £153,212 (2024) |
| 51 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £169,334 (2024) |
| 53 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £169,334 (2024) |
| 55 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £305,168 (2025) |
| 57 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 80 m² | £310,337 (2024) |
| 59 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 75 m² | £276,371 (2025) |
| 61 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 75 m² | £289,995 (2024) |
