| 2 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 78 m² | £279,995 (2023) |
| 4 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 98 m² | - |
| 6 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 98 m² | - |
| 8 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 98 m² | £212,337 (2023) |
| 10 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £162,792 (2023) |
| 12 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £162,792 (2023) |
| 14 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 16 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 18 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 20 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 22 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 24 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 64 m² | £143,346 (2024) |
| 26 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £263,397 (2024) |
| 28 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £266,887 (2025) |
| 30 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 75 m² | £168,834 (2025) |
| 32 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 75 m² | £168,834 (2025) |
| 34 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,864 (2024) |
| 36 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,864 (2024) |
| 38 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 78 m² | £275,995 (2024) |
| 40 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,799 (2024) |
| 42 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,799 (2024) |
| 44 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 78 m² | £289,757 (2024) |
| 46 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | - | 76 m² | - |
| 48 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £168,941 (2024) |
| 50 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 76 m² | - |
| 52 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 76 m² | - |
| 54 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £273,596 (2024) |
| 56 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £263,995 (2025) |
| 58 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 76 m² | - |
| 60 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,578 (2024) |
| 62 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 63 m² | £56,237 (2025) |
| 64 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,578 (2024) |
| 66 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £168,941 (2024) |
| 68 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £168,941 (2024) |
| 70 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £168,941 (2024) |
| 72 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Barnsley | Freehold | 76 m² | £168,941 (2024) |
| 74 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,864 (2024) |
| 76 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,864 (2024) |
| 78 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 63 m² | £143,864 (2024) |
| 80 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 56 m² | £213,746 (2025) |
| 82 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 56 m² | £219,995 (2025) |
| 84 Castle Garden Street, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 56 m² | £227,996 (2024) |