| 1, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 91 m² | £219,950 (2016) |
| 2, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 91 m² | £184,950 (2016) |
| 3, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 93 m² | £199,950 (2016) |
| 4, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £184,950 (2016) |
| 5, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 69 m² | £2,000 (2026) |
| 6, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 114 m² | £304,950 (2018) |
| 7, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 69 m² | £2,000 (2026) |
| 8, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 88 m² | £231,950 (2018) |
| 9, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 129 m² | £289,950 (2016) |
| 10, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | - | 91 m² | - |
| 11, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 114 m² | £269,950 (2016) |
| 12, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £212,500 (2022) |
| 14, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £169,950 (2016) |
| 15, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 112 m² | £328,000 (2025) |
| 16, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £229,000 (2025) |
| 17, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £282,500 (2022) |
| 18, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £245,000 (2022) |
| 19, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 108 m² | £244,950 (2016) |
| 20, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 91 m² | £219,950 (2016) |
| 21, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 108 m² | £249,950 (2016) |
| 22, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £199,950 (2016) |
| 23, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 114 m² | £264,950 (2016) |
| 24, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 108 m² | £307,000 (2021) |
| 25, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £324,995 (2023) |
| 26, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £149,950 (2016) |
| 27, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £265,000 (2021) |
| 28, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £149,950 (2016) |
| 29, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 108 m² | £370,000 (2023) |
| 30, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 112 m² | £264,950 (2016) |
| 31, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £195,000 (2021) |
| 32, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 112 m² | £264,950 (2016) |
| 33, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £242,000 (2023) |
| 34, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £225,000 (2022) |
| 35, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £180,000 (2018) |
| 36, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £240,000 (2023) |
| 37, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £161,950 (2017) |
| 38, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £237,500 (2024) |
| 39, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 84 m² | £197,000 (2020) |
| 40, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £233,000 (2022) |
| 41, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 84 m² | £235,000 (2024) |
| 42, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £284,000 (2021) |
| 43, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £174,950 (2017) |
| 44, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £320,000 (2026) |
| 45, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £208,000 (2021) |
| 46, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 129 m² | £309,950 (2017) |
| 47, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 100 m² | £254,950 (2017) |
| 48, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 114 m² | £417,000 (2026) |
| 49, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 82 m² | £199,950 (2017) |
| 50, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 88 m² | £320,000 (2023) |
| 51, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £158,950 (2017) |
| 52 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 53, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Leasehold | 69 m² | £164,950 (2017) |
| 54 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 56 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 58 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 60 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 62 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 60 m² | £70,570 (2017) |
| 64, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 81 m² | £70,560 (2017) |
| 66 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £70,580 (2017) |
| 68 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 82 m² | £70,580 (2017) |
| 70 New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 76 m² | £70,580 (2017) |
| 72, New Chapel Road, Penistone, Sheffield | Freehold | 81 m² | £70,580 (2017) |
