| 1A Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 64 m² | - |
| 2, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 93 m² | £170,000 (2025) |
| 3A Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 54 m² | - |
| 4, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 49 m² | £120,000 (2013) |
| 7, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 55 m² | £48,250 (2002) |
| 7A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 55 m² | £64,000 (2023) |
| 9 Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 51 m² | £68,000 (2023) |
| 9A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 52 m² | £70,000 (2025) |
| 10, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 57 m² | £115,000 (2011) |
| 11, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 52 m² | £65,100 (2016) |
| 11A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 51 m² | £58,000 (2019) |
| 12, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 65 m² | £132,500 (2014) |
| 15A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 54 m² | £36,500 (2001) |
| 17, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 52 m² | £48,500 (2018) |
| 17A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 53 m² | - |
| 19, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 52 m² | - |
| 19A, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 53 m² | £60,000 (2023) |
| 19B Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 51 m² | £25,000 (2000) |
| 19C Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Leasehold | 53 m² | £65,000 (2003) |
| 20, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 58 m² | £102,000 (2013) |
| 21 Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 108 m² | - |
| 22, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | - | 62 m² | - |
| 23, Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 127 m² | £248,000 (2022) |
| 24 Otterburn Gardens, Middlesbrough | Freehold | 88 m² | £120,000 (2018) |
