| 1 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | - | 64 m² | - |
| 2 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 126 m² | £115,000 (2002) |
| 5 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 201 m² | £620,000 (2023) |
| 6, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 159 m² | £200,000 (2008) |
| 8 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 94 m² | £295,000 (2025) |
| 12, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 146 m² | £77,500 (1996) |
| 14 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 169 m² | £370,000 (2014) |
| 20A Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 90 m² | £235,000 (2025) |
| 24, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 275 m² | £345,000 (2017) |
| 29, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | - | 28 m² | - |
| 30 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 174 m² | £310,000 (2024) |
| 32 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 112 m² | £280,000 (2025) |
| 36, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | - | 56 m² | - |
| 38 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 86 m² | £150,000 (2024) |
| 40 Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 93 m² | £205,000 (2025) |
| Ivy Cottage, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | Freehold | 189 m² | £375,000 (2025) |
| Woodend, Castlegate, East Ayton, Scarborough | - | 282 m² | - |
