| 1 Amotherby Close, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 95 m² | £320,000 (2022) |
| 2 Amotherby Close, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 98 m² | £190,000 (2016) |
| 3 Amotherby Close, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 97 m² | £265,000 (2022) |
| Ash Tree Rise Amotherby Close, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 125 m² | £340,000 (2017) |
| Beech Garth Amotherby, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 134 m² | £310,000 (2021) |
| Bentley House, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 201 m² | £390,000 (2017) |
| Cairn Cottage, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 164 m² | £550,000 (2022) |
| Carpenters Croft, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 203 m² | £435,000 (2010) |
| East Rise, Amotherby, Malton | - | 147 m² | - |
| Glencoe, Amotherby, Malton | - | 141 m² | - |
| Glenmore, Amotherby, Malton | - | 152 m² | - |
| Granary Barn, Amotherby, Malton | - | 412 m² | - |
| Lime Kiln Farm, Amotherby Lane To Lime Kiln Farm, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 198 m² | £1,194,400 (2020) |
| Manor Farm, Amotherby, Malton | - | 377 m² | - |
| Manor Rise, Amotherby, Malton | - | 156 m² | - |
| Manor View, Amotherby Close, Amotherby, Malton | - | 138 m² | - |
| Plum Tree Cottage, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 127 m² | £187,805 (2002) |
| Porch House, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 179 m² | £445,000 (2020) |
| Pump House, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 109 m² | £315,000 (2019) |
| Southfield House, Amotherby, Malton | - | 109 m² | - |
| The Bungalow, Manor Farm, Amotherby Lane To Lime Kiln Farm, Malton | Freehold | 67 m² | £140,000 (2022) |
| The Manor House, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 312 m² | £955,000 (2020) |
| The Old Forge, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 67 m² | £187,500 (2025) |
| The Old School, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 221 m² | £450,000 (2017) |
| The Spinney, Amotherby, Malton | Freehold | 167 m² | £422,500 (2015) |
| Winifred Farm, Amotherby, Malton | - | 197 m² | - |
