| 1 Forge Cottages, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 68 m² | - |
| 1 Horse House Farm Cottages, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 98 m² | - |
| 2 Horse House Farm Cottages, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 109 m² | - |
| 3 Forge Cottages, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 78 m² | £215,000 (2023) |
| 8 Forge Cottages, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 68 m² | £205,000 (2021) |
| Brookside Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 76 m² | £243,000 (2022) |
| Cherry Tree Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 76 m² | - |
| Chestnut Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 70 m² | - |
| Fern Cottage, Village Street, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 139 m² | - |
| Forge House, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 200 m² | £520,000 (2025) |
| Hawthorne Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 74 m² | - |
| High Park Farm, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 191 m² | - |
| Island Cottage, Village Street, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 92 m² | £243,000 (2019) |
| Laburnum Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 76 m² | - |
| Laurel Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 76 m² | - |
| Mill Race House, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 154 m² | £385,000 (2010) |
| Mulberry House, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 119 m² | - |
| Pine Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 74 m² | - |
| Poets Cottage, Village Street, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 168 m² | - |
| Shepherds Hall, Village Street, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 87 m² | £300,000 (2025) |
| Stone Villa, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 226 m² | £475,000 (2026) |
| The Coach House, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 180 m² | £355,000 (2013) |
| The Forge, Village Street, Lealholm, Whitby | Freehold | 131 m² | £350,000 (2021) |
| The Hollies, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 84 m² | - |
| The Mill House, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 316 m² | - |
| Yew Cottage, Lealholm, Whitby | - | 96 m² | - |
