| 2 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 182 m² | £430,000 (2022) |
| 10, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 168 m² | - |
| 12, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 63 m² | £172,500 (2019) |
| 18, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 73 m² | - |
| 20A High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 113 m² | £56,000 (1996) |
| 22, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 154 m² | - |
| 26, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 70 m² | £172,500 (2020) |
| 30 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 180 m² | £239,950 (2009) |
| 32 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 129 m² | - |
| 34 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 104 m² | £336,000 (2023) |
| 40 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 169 m² | £315,000 (2018) |
| 42, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 130 m² | £260,000 (2018) |
| 44, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 77 m² | £167,500 (2018) |
| 46 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 292 m² | £650,000 (2023) |
| 50 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 116 m² | £340,000 (2024) |
| 56, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 51 m² | £443,000 (2022) |
| 58 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 167 m² | £290,000 (2012) |
| 60, High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 103 m² | £150,000 (2009) |
| Hawthorn Cottage, 4 High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 116 m² | £220,000 (2025) |
| Hazel Cottage, 4A High Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 104 m² | £212,500 (2024) |