| 1 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 74 m² | - |
| 3, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 151 m² | £57,000 (1995) |
| 4 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 102 m² | £175,000 (2025) |
| 5, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 113 m² | - |
| 6 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 157 m² | £295,500 (2026) |
| 7, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 45 m² | £99,000 (2019) |
| 8 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 97 m² | £180,000 (2020) |
| 9 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 98 m² | £227,000 (2022) |
| 10, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 95 m² | £146,000 (2018) |
| 11 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 90 m² | £140,000 (2005) |
| 12 Church Street, Castleton | - | 105 m² | - |
| 13 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 71 m² | £170,000 (2026) |
| 14 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 127 m² | £290,000 (2021) |
| 15 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 72 m² | - |
| 16, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 72 m² | - |
| 17, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 105 m² | £134,000 (2011) |
| 18, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 91 m² | £190,000 (2020) |
| 19 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 103 m² | - |
| 20, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 121 m² | - |
| 22 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 134 m² | - |
| 24 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 108 m² | £148,000 (2011) |
| 26, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 194 m² | - |
| 28A Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 81 m² | - |
| 28B Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 85 m² | - |
| 30A Church Street, Castleton, Whitby, Whitby | - | 81 m² | - |
| 32 Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 94 m² | £200,000 (2025) |
| 34, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 142 m² | - |
| 38, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | Freehold | 82 m² | £245,000 (2022) |
| Flat, 12, Church Street, Castleton, Whitby | - | 114 m² | - |