| Abingdon House, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 85 m² | - |
| Ash Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 70 m² | - |
| Bank Top Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 96 m² | - |
| Caledonia House, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 120 m² | - |
| Chapel Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 99 m² | £263,000 (2018) |
| Chestnut Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 70 m² | - |
| Cobbler Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 72 m² | - |
| Curlew Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 57 m² | - |
| Damson Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 90 m² | - |
| Hawthorn Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 69 m² | - |
| Hazel Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 73 m² | - |
| High Farm, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 175 m² | - |
| Holly Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 132 m² | - |
| Homestead Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 95 m² | - |
| Kerrs Farm, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 105 m² | - |
| Kipling Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 73 m² | £170,000 (2017) |
| Langley Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 57 m² | - |
| Laurel Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 101 m² | £120,000 (2013) |
| Low Farm, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 144 m² | - |
| Lythe Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 43 m² | £165,000 (2023) |
| Meadowfield House, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 125 m² | £340,000 (2025) |
| Middle Farm, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 135 m² | - |
| Oak Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 71 m² | - |
| Oakdene, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 109 m² | £282,000 (2023) |
| Rose Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 78 m² | - |
| Sea Wood View, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 95 m² | - |
| Skelder View, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 122 m² | - |
| The Nest, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | Freehold | 124 m² | £80,000 (1998) |
| Topcliffe House, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 82 m² | - |
| Wayside Cottage, High Street, Lythe, Whitby | - | 71 m² | - |