| Aero View, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 128 m² | £330,000 (2010) |
| Annexe, Beckside Farm, Main Street, Tholthorpe | - | 77 m² | - |
| Barn House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 183 m² | £430,000 (2017) |
| Beckside Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 86 m² | £76,000 (1998) |
| Beckside Farm, Tholthorpe, York | - | 173 m² | - |
| Blossom Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 72 m² | £325,000 (2024) |
| Braeburn Lodge, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 199 m² | £592,500 (2024) |
| Cornfields, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 117 m² | £280,000 (2011) |
| Flat 1, The Granary, Tholthorpe, York | - | 70 m² | - |
| Flat 2, The Granary, Tholthorpe, York | - | 71 m² | - |
| Hambleton Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 147 m² | £458,150 (2024) |
| Hamilton House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 166 m² | £569,950 (2021) |
| Hillcrest, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 107 m² | £262,500 (2012) |
| Holly Bank, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 148 m² | £337,500 (2018) |
| Holly Tree House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 123 m² | £525,000 (2025) |
| Ivy House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 170 m² | £402,500 (2010) |
| Maycroft, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 97 m² | £282,500 (2017) |
| New Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 114 m² | £215,000 (2011) |
| Orchard House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 198 m² | £530,000 (2016) |
| Pear Tree House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 200 m² | £465,000 (2016) |
| Pemberton House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 189 m² | £405,000 (2012) |
| Plough Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 116 m² | £282,500 (2020) |
| Pond Farm, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 215 m² | £650,000 (2012) |
| Richmond House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 114 m² | £275,000 (2012) |
| Rose Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | - | 79 m² | - |
| Rose Dene, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 277 m² | £430,000 (2011) |
| Roselea Cottage, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 115 m² | £415,000 (2025) |
| Rosewood House, Main Street, Tholthorpe, Tholthorpe | - | 160 m² | - |
| Saxdene, Tholthorpe, York | - | 143 m² | - |
| Schilde Lodge, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 344 m² | £815,000 (2021) |
| Skelwith Granary, Main Street, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 105 m² | £475,000 (2024) |
| Stable Cottage, Main Street, Tholthorpe | - | 110 m² | - |
| Stock Ghyll Barn, Main Street, Tholthorpe | Freehold | 300 m² | £1,100,000 (2025) |
| Tennant House, Tholthorpe, York | - | 190 m² | - |
| The Barn Manor Farm, Tholthorpe, York | - | 262 m² | - |
| The Garth, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 184 m² | £135,000 (2000) |
| The Laurels, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 130 m² | £382,500 (2016) |
| The Lodge, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 114 m² | £255,000 (2017) |
| The Plough, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 170 m² | £510,000 (2020) |
| The Willows, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 115 m² | £250,000 (2010) |
| Wallace House, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 105 m² | £280,000 (2013) |
| Waterside Lodge, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 170 m² | £460,000 (2009) |
| Woodstock, Tholthorpe, York | Freehold | 144 m² | £395,000 (2011) |