| (Marshall) Sunnyside, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 121 m² | - |
| Appletree Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 78 m² | £165,000 (2013) |
| Ashmount, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 233 m² | £285,000 (2020) |
| Bagby Hall Farm, Bagby Village, Bagby, Bagby | Freehold | 201 m² | £475,000 (2021) |
| Beech Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 78 m² | £208,500 (2018) |
| Briardene, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 134 m² | £80,000 (1996) |
| Byland Bungalow, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 116 m² | £63,000 (1995) |
| Cherry Tree Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 145 m² | - |
| Church Farm, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 280 m² | £165,000 (1999) |
| Church Hall, Bagby Village Track Near Church Lane, Bagby | - | 187 m² | - |
| Coldstream, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 62 m² | £289,500 (2019) |
| Crossley Garth, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 95 m² | £65,000 (1996) |
| Fair View, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 98 m² | £275,000 (2022) |
| Green Garth, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 75 m² | - |
| Green Leas, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 129 m² | £425,000 (2019) |
| Greenfield House, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 275 m² | £550,000 (2021) |
| Harmony House, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 257 m² | £750,000 (2024) |
| Hillside Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 79 m² | £265,000 (2016) |
| Hollygarth, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 136 m² | £249,999 (2004) |
| Langton, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 122 m² | £182,500 (2002) |
| Laurel Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 230 m² | £681,256 (2021) |
| Longacres, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 134 m² | - |
| Lyngarth, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 76 m² | - |
| Maple Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 70 m² | £305,000 (2025) |
| New House, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 120 m² | £280,000 (2020) |
| Oaklands, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 180 m² | £405,000 (2020) |
| Paddock House, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 238 m² | £467,000 (2007) |
| Paddock View, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 122 m² | £338,500 (2023) |
| Penny Post, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 118 m² | £295,000 (2014) |
| Rosamunde, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 78 m² | £160,000 (2016) |
| Rowan, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 112 m² | - |
| Smithy Farm Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 119 m² | - |
| Smithy Farm, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 97 m² | - |
| Stable Cottage, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 103 m² | £205,000 (2019) |
| The Gables, Bagby Village, Bagby, Bagby | - | 209 m² | - |
| The Old School Church Close, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 218 m² | £325,000 (2007) |
| The Villa, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 166 m² | £415,000 (2019) |
| Westlands, Bagby, Thirsk | - | 101 m² | - |
| Westwood, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 128 m² | £250,000 (2013) |
| White Lodge, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 215 m² | £265,000 (2016) |
| Willow Garth, Bagby, Thirsk | Freehold | 106 m² | £214,999 (2012) |
